Image Courtesy of FiveThirtyEight
By Anthony Curioso
The announcement of Bill Belichick’s departure from the New England Patriots following the 2023-24 NFL regular season was just the latest low point in the downward spiral recently suffered by Boston area sports teams.
Many fans believe the announcement has officially marked the end of the era of dominance that the Boston sports teams and their fans experienced in the twenty-first century.
Boston’s sports teams had an incredibly successful run during the first two decades of this century. It all started with the Patriots’ victory over the then-Saint Louis Rams in the 2002 Super Bowl. The Red Sox won four MLB World Series titles over the following twenty years, while the Patriots won five more Super Bowls. The Bruins and the Celtics also had their fair share of success, with the former winning the Stanley Cup Finals once (in 2011) and the latter winning the NBA Finals once (in 2008), and both teams having made three appearances in their respective finals. Boston’s sports teams have clearly been dominant across all arenas for a long time.
In between the times of success, there were some years where the teams struggled. However, this recent dry spell amongst Bostonian teams appears more like a desert than a drought.
Multiple last-place finishes by the Red Sox and Patriots over the last several years, combined with recent early-round exits and heartbreaking defeats in the playoffs for the Bruins and Celtics, indicate that Boston teams are not playing with the same success that many Bostonians have come to expect.
These disappointing performances by the Boston sports teams have left many local fans unwilling even to watch their teams’ games anymore because they simply can’t handle the pain.
Where does this leave sports fans now? Which US or Canadian city will become the next great “sports haven”? The answer to this question is “It depends.”
One would be hard-pressed to find another city with consistent sports success rivaling Boston’s. For this reason, it is too early to pinpoint one city that is most likely to achieve the same level of sports success, if it is even possible for a city to do so.
If forced to pick a new champion, the Browns and Guardians have had several promising seasons over the past decade. The Cavaliers seem to be turning a corner (they are currently in fifth place in the NBA’s Eastern Conference after a few years of losing). Given that all three teams have many young and talented players, perhaps the city of Cleveland will become the next dynasty city.