X-Men: The Last Stand Remains a Juggernaut of a Disappointment

0
049

Image Courtesy of Marvel Entertainment

By Luis Zonenberg

Continuing the countdown to Avengers: Doomsday, I wanted to take a moment to look back on some of the X-Men films in light of Patrick Stewart’s passing. With the film celebrating its 20th anniversary, I figured it was best to revisit the rather controversial X-Men: The Last Stand. The film had an incredibly messy transition to the big screen, with producers clashing with each other over the direction of the story. Does this film deserve the hate it gets from fans, or is it an overlooked gem hiding in the sand? Well, let’s dive in and find out!

The story focuses on Wolverine (Hugh Jackman) supervising the X-Men since Cyclops (James Marsden) stepped down as team leader following the death of his girlfriend, Jean Grey (Famke Janssen). Things soon spiral out of control once they discover Jean has somehow come back to life, shortly after the mysterious disappearance of Cyclops. They soon find out a dormant side of her psyche called “the Phoenix” has awakened, causing her to wreak havoc and ultimately murder Professor Xavier (Patrick Stewart).

Jean soon seeks solace with Magneto (Ian McKellen) and his band of mutant protestors following her fight with the X-Men. Unbeknownst to her, Magneto seeks to utilize Jean’s abilities to attack a human movement that’s pushing for a potential cure for mutations. Fearing both Jean and Magneto will cause irreparable damage, Wolverine must embrace his role as team leader to guide the X-Men into what might be their greatest battle yet! 

The story remains a cluttered mess, juggling two different storylines with no clear direction or satisfying payoff. This is not surprising since the film’s producers smashed together two separate scripts, one written by Zak Penn and the other by Simon Kinberg, since they could not decide on a clear direction for the film. This is painfully evident throughout the movie, as both feel awkwardly rushed and compete for screen time in a film that is not even two hours long!

The film surprisingly asks some timely questions, like whether minorities such as the mutant population should consider using the cure. Are their abilities nothing more than an affliction you can treat like a disease, or is it a biological component they will be robbing themselves of if they take it? It simply poses the question of conforming to social standards and whether or not this robs them of their unique gifts. These are interesting moral dilemmas that are unfortunately left with no clear answer, with no satisfying revelation that ties into the story or the character’s arcs. 

Thankfully, the cast carries the film with their entertaining performances, particularly Hugh Jackman. His gruff demeanor and candid personality capture the essence of his character while furthering his character’s arc from the previous films. Ian McKellen is another standout as Magneto, with his iconic voice and incredible stage presence adding real gravitas to the film. Other actors like Patrick Stewart, Halle Berry, Kelsey Grammer, and Elliott Page anchor the film with their committed performances. 

While the cinematography is nothing breathtaking, it injects much-needed energy into the film. The creative angles and wide shots capture the epic weight of the story, making the action feel more grand in scale. However, the photography also utilizes a muted color palette, creating a gritty visual look that clashes with the more fantastical elements of the story. While this visual aesthetic may not match the film’s tone, it at least captures the frenetic energy and epic scale of a superhero fight. 

The VFX is a mixed bag, with the CGI in particular sticking out like a sore thumb. The film’s CGI was rendered in a much lower resolution than what it was filmed in, causing it to look cheaper and blurrier than it should. Thankfully, the makeup and practical set pieces help balance it out, leaning into the character’s unique designs while making them look more realistic. Even if the CGI does not hold up well, the makeup and practical sets help sell the illusion of a superhero epic. 

Twenty years later, the movie remains a disappointing mess that squanders the potential of two great X-Men stories. Had the filmmakers chosen to focus on just one of these storylines, they could have developed a clearer and more compelling story that would entertain long-time fans of the comics. Even if the action and performances are entertaining in their own right, X-Men: The Last Stand crumbles under the weight of its cluttered story. 

X-Men: The Last Stand is now available to purchase on digital retailers. 

Rating: ★★ ½ of five

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *